This critical thinking exercise is based on a current news article in which a young woman was arrested for selling $400 worth of heroin to an undercover police officer in 1974.
She was sentenced to a 10-20 year prison term, but escaped after 8 months. She had become a model citizen with 3 children that she had raised as model citizens.
See the Resources area below for additional CT teaching and learning activity ideas! Design scoring tools for evaluating critical-thinking-oriented assignments. Even if you do not intend to only include critical thinking criteria in evaluating student work, these resources can suggest criteria for your customized rubric or list of assignment specifications.
Student Engagement Techniques (E Barkley): Chap 13 (Analysis and Critical Thinking)Engaging Ideas (J Bean): Chap 2 (How Writing is Related to Critical Thinking..T&L activities; more philosophical); Chap 7, pgs 122-137 (10 Strategies for Designing Critical Thinking Tasks); Chap 9 (Coaching Thinking through the Use of Small Groups)Teaching for Critical Thinking (S Brookfield): Chap 6 Reading and Writing Critically; Chap 4, p. Ruggiero has written several others books on teaching critical thinking, as well.
Again, start with a question, but this time ask the students to debate the topic by having the conversation entirely on paper, in complete silence.
Opinions can be expressed in writing or pictures, making this a fun, creative exercise.How can teachers incorporate an engaging critical thinking exercise into existing lessons plans?Below are 5 fun ideas – which consider Macat’s unique PACIER critical thinking model, developed with The University of Cambridge – that you can implement today!This gives those who are commonly quiet in debates or not as strong at verbal communication a level playing field with other students to express their views.Break the class up into group of two or three, providing them with a large sheet of clipboard paper and pens.As you know, K-12 education is primarily about learning the basics, i.e., facts, concepts, principles, and skills.Although critical thinking and problem-solving skills are included to some extent, they are not the primary focus. We continue to teach the basics in introductory courses especially, but the primary goal is for students to use that knowledge to think critically about events, readings, speeches, ideas, and one's own perspectives across many disciplines.Ask the panel to present their answers to the rest of the class, then give the class time to ask the panel questions about their stories.After a set period of time, ask students to vote which story they think is the truth, before revealing the correct answer.She was returned to Michigan to complete her jail sentence.Her family and friends petitioned the governor for clemency.